Disclaimer: When readers buy products and services discussed on our site, we often earn affiliate commissions that support our work. More details

How to Make Vegan Cheese

If you are vegan and you love cheese, it means that your decision to make the switch to the vegan lifestyle was the toughest thing you ever did.

Cheese is the best thing Mother Nature’s bestowed on us, but being vegan means that you cannot enjoy the dairy cheese options anymore, and this translates to you getting annoyed anytime your non-vegan friends talk about their deep love for cheese.

But that doesn’t have to be the case anymore, and you can finally get your fill of vegan-friendly cheeses over brunch thanks to all the vegan options you can make at home.

The interesting bit is that until today, you were not aware of all these creative, super healthy, and very simple cheese options at your disposal, and we are changing that, starting now.

You can finally indulge in cheesy goodness from cheeses made from nuts and other plant-based ingredients that match your ethos. You might also like the versatility that lies in the world of vegan cheeses, and just how much food fun you’ve been missing out on.

In addition to having the best vegan cheeses to pair with your wine, you could also enjoy these options in your pasta dishes, as spreads, and basically anything else that needs a kick.

So, how do you make the healthiest vegan cheese at home?

Aware that you don’t have much time to wait for your cheese to age and that this is most probably your first time trying to make vegan cheese (or any other cheese for that matter), this recipe is one of the simplest cheese-making recipes you’ll find.

Keep in mind that besides the vegan lifestyle, the vegan cheeses are also an excellent alternative for people struggling with lactose intolerance.

The Making of Vegan Cheese

How to Make Vegan Cheese

Before we look at the recipe, it’s important to note that the animal-based cheeses have animal rennet, which is the enzyme that enhances coagulation, while separating whey and the curds. As a result, they do not fall in the vegan or even the vegetarian category.

For a cheese to be classified as vegan should be free of dairy and rennet.

Therefore, instead of dairy, you need to find plant-based substitutes such as nuts, nutritional yeasts, vegetable oils, tofu, or soy proteins for you to attain the texture and flavor of the cheese.

Depending on how you mix and make the cheese, the cheese you make could be soft and easy to spread or hard and easily sliced.

Going vegan means no dairy products, but that doesn’t mean you can’t have milk.

Simple Vegan Cheese Recipe

In this cheese recipe, we’ll make a cheese recipe out of unsalted cashews, no milk, and no rennet.

Ingredients

  • For the simplest vegan cheese recipes, you’ll need some nuts, squeezed lemon juice/ splash of water, and herbs. For starters, you’d need 2 cups of raw, unsalted cashews. Nuts make a great base for the spreads since they are protein-packed and flavorful. The nuts also add texture. You might want to pre-soak the nuts in water for about 4 hours before you start, to soften the nuts. Even with the most powerful processor, pre-soaking ensures that you achieve a good consistency for your mixture.
  • 1 or 1.5 cups of malted or raw grains
  • Some salt to taste

Getting Started

The vegan cheese preparation steps and recipes all involve the separation of plant-bacteria by the use of bacteria cultures before the addition of oils and thickeners to ensure the creation of that desired cheese-like consistency.

Like the traditional dairy cheese, the vegetable proteins and the bacteria need to sit for some time for further breakdown and for the development of the perfect flavors.

Preparing the Lactic Starter

How to Make Vegan Cheese

To prepare your vegan cheese, you first need to prepare your starter culture – this culture is similar to the one you’d use to make pickles or sauerkraut. For the cheese, you need a lactic bacteria starter culture.

For the culture, you need all grains like barley, wheat, and rice since they all come with their own large populations of natural bacteria.

To access the bacteria culture, we have to change the grains a bit. Here’s how:

First, select your grains, and then after soaking for a few days and rinsing, you will see some sprouts forming. The sprouting is a natural process in all seeds/ grains, and it signals that the starch in the seeds/ grains is more accessible to be fed on by bacteria.

Alternatively, you could start with malted wheat or barley since the malting process makes the starch available and the grains ready for fermentation.

Next up, take the malted or the sprouted grains and add them to a jar of water at room temperature. Then, take the grains in the jar and keep them in a quiet room, at room temperature for 2-3 days.

At this time, you will start seeing bubbling and notice a tangy flavor. These changes are initiated by the enzymes present in the grains and the growing lactic bacteria. This is your lactic starter culture, the primary ingredient for cheese making.

You will use this lactic starter culture to ferment the sugars present in your cashews. The culture also creates that nice tangy flavor you have been looking for.

Note that when you begin to taste the tanginess, you should transfer your mixture to the fridge for things to cool down.

Keep the culture refrigerated for a few weeks while keeping the bacteria active.

Soaking your Cashews

How to Make Vegan Cheese

As mentioned above, you need to soak your cashews, about 2 cups for 6-8hours. Once the cashews are soaked, drain them then transfer them to a blender or a food processor.

Blending

Here, you are blending your culture with the soaked cashews. Add about ¼ cup of your starter culture to the soaked cashews then blend. Add agar agar here (agar agar is a vegan replacement for gelatin, derived from seaweed.

It swells when mixed with water and forms a jelly-like mixture, without altering the taste). For the best results, start from the pulse/ coarse chop function before you switch to a slower speed for the perfect paste.

Add the other ¼ cup of the starter culture and keep blending until you create a smooth paste. Like any other paste you may have prepared in the past, you’ll have to stop and scrape the paste off the back of the processor or blender frequently.

Once you have a smooth paste, transfer it to a bowl, then add sugar and your active bacteria culture – this culture will be ready to convert the sugars in the cashews into lactic acid. Transfer your paste to a covered bowl.

Fermentation

Now that you’ve done all the necessary hard work, it’s time for the mixture to sit pretty and turn into the best cheese.

For that to happen, keep the paste in a quiet room at room temperature. After 2 days or so, you will notice that the flavor of the paste turns from sweet to tangy.

The change results from the action of lactic acid in the starter culture, which converts the sugars in the paste into lactic acid.

Let the fermentation process go on until the flavor feels right to you – not everyone likes tangy/ acidic, and you might like your cheese sweeter.

So, keep checking until the desired taste is achieved.

As soon as the taste feels right to you, refrigerate your vegan cheese, and if it feels too dry, add some water or lemon juice. The latter introduces a fresh flavor.

Ready Cheese

To enjoy your fresh cheese, leave it in a bowl as a spread or roll it into a log-like form and then mix in any spices or herbs you’d like in your cheese.

Storage

After all that work, you want your cheese to last a few weeks. So, wrap it in a breathable wrap in a covered plastic container.

FAQs

Does Vegan Cheese Taste like Dairy Cheese

The one thing you will notice about the vegan cheese is that its flavors will not be as developed as the flavors of the dairy cheese.

Vegan cheese doesn’t melt the same way, and it won’t have that ooey-gooey feel and look expected on your pizza from dairy cheese. But with time and experience, you’ll create the vegan cheese with the perfect flavors, texture, and consistency.

How Long Does Vegan Cheese Last?

If stores right (in an airtight container), the cheese should last for up to 2 weeks. For it to last longer, you could keep some of it frozen then thaw when ready to use.

Does Vegan Cheese Melt?

Yes, but not in the same way as dairy cheese.

But since the cheese has agar agar and coconut oil, the cheese will respond to different temperature conditions appropriately.

Therefore, you can put the cheese on pizza and grilled foods. For looser vegan cheese that melts, reduce the amount of agar agar used, say from 5 to 3 spoonful, and for thicker and harder cheese, you’d require more agar agar and also leave the cheese in the fridge for longer.

Can You Make Different Varieties of Vegan Cheese?

Yes. Even though the cheese created from the recipe above will have that white cheddar-like taste, given you out the right amount of salt, you can achieve different flavors and tastes by changing the ingredients.

You can reduce the salt, add spices, fresh, or dry herbs to make different varieties. You can add anything from cayenne pepper to black pepper, chives, or dill.

Leave a Comment